Canadian Medal of  

          Honor.com

  • Sunday evening's blogs
  • graves, memorials and medals
  • About the Author
  • contact the Author
  • Home

Founded as a place to rest, but about 1,000 would die there... per hour... every hour...for three devastating days

11/29/2013

0 Comments

 
It would be about 100 years earlier when an Irishman had founded a little merchant and  tavern business in Pennsylvania. It was to be a place for the soldiers to rest for awhile. His son would later lay out a little community of 120 lots and of course it would all be named after his father Sam. Samuel Getty. By then they had added the letter "S" to their original surname and the community became his burgh (town). Today we call it Gettysburg.

People across the United States, and indeed the world were keeping score of Gettysburg last week, In fact they were also reflecting on the terrible tragedy that took the life of John F Kennedy twoscore and ten years ago.

But sevenscore and ten years ago the 272 words including that "the world will little note nor long remember what we say here,"  were spoken to thousands gathered, and they are still very well known today.  As they should be!

Abraham Lincoln had taken the noon train the day on 18 November 1863 at Washington DC and travelled with a large entourage of officials to Gettysburg in the late afternoon and spent the night at the Wills house. Wills being the very lawyer who was so instrumental in helping to start a cemetery for the thousands that were still laying on the ground they died on days after the horrendous battles across some 25 acres of land named in honour of Sam Gettys. Those horrific days of July 1-3, to be remembered forever.
Picture
Just south of town the Gettysburg National Cemetery was laid out. This cemetery backed up against another already in place on Cemetery Hill and known as the Everygreen Cemetery. On the 19th a military parade led the way out of town to the National Cemetery. The  President rode out in that parade on a horse and this wollen covered wooden saddle is what he rode on. Today it is an exibit at the Wills house at the centre of town, and the very building that the Medal of Honor memorial was unveiled whist I was in Gettysburg in mid September. 

Many of the public raced on ahead of the parade and entered to get best viewing by using the adjoining Evergreen and passed through the gatehouse shown above. A sign then posted at its entrance warned that..." All persons found using firearms on these grounds will be prosecuted with the utmost rigor of law." One must wonder if that sign existed three months months earlier during the deady battle, fought in part, on the very land that was then, and is today, part of Evergreen.  

Picture










The Tyson Brothers Photography Studio of Gettysburg  were two of over 500 photographers that made pictures during the Civil War. The brothers were among about 45 at Gettysburg. The image on the left was taking by them about 11.30 in the forenoon and shows a street now called Baltimore, and  heading into the town. You are looking Northbound. The building on the left is at the corner of a street heading of to the left, as you look at the picture  (Westbound) and is today known as Steinwehr Avenue. The building still stands today.

A few minutes later the parade started to arrive and head off up Steinwehr to the entrance of the National Cemetery. If you enlarge the image on the right several ranks of military become quite obvious.

Picture













Here's a view on the same area taken not long ago, and a map of the immediate area. The intersection is just above the letter "A" on right image.

The "A" actually marks the spot where Jennie Wade was killed. Twenty year old Jennie was visiting a sister who had just given birth a few days earlier. Jennie and family were visiting and helping out. The house was located between no mans' land between the Confederates off to the left and the Union off to the right. During the three day battle Jennie and others baked bread and biscuttes for the Union soldiers and had awaken earlier one morning to place the bread kneaded the day before into an oven when a minnie ball shot rang out, traveled right through two doors and instantly killed her.

While the house was hit about 150 times during the three day battle, Jennie would become the ONLY civilian to die at Gettysburg. With some 125,000 battling it out, she'd be the only civilan casualty. She would later be buried at Everygreen, and quite close to the fence seperating it from the national cemetery.
Note both cemeteries also on the above map.

Picture
This picture was taken also during Lincoln's Gettysburg Address. Over the years it has been analysed and recently a surprising result came from all the work. In the midst of all of this experts have determined where Lincoln is in the crowd and where the actual address took place. 

As you look at the photo you are looking eastbound. The town is off to the left. The flag pole on the left is now marked by the National Monument shown within the semi-circle in the photo 2 down. The Evergreen Cemetery's gatehouse shown above, and also in the top picture in this blog, is also shown in the picture below this one.  It is just left of the green arrow locating on the highway running from the top to bottom near the right side of image.

But this gatehouse is further back and at the road.  The crowd scene is much closer to the foreground in the image. 

Picture
Look to the left of the green arrow to about mid page where you will see a very clear white circle with a monument in white at its centre. The is the National Monument..which is on the ground the above flag pole once stood. Below is a better shot of this.

Picture
The Gettysburg National Cemetery is on the top in this image and the Evergreen Cemetery is at the bottom of course. Just below the clump of trees is believed to be the fence line separating both cemeteries. At the centre is a map marker between two clups of trees. This is supposed to mark the location of Jennie Wade's grave stone but I believe the marker is too high up the page and should be just below the fence line. 

Still farther down slightly... and to the left is another marker. It is in this very area that it is believed Abraham Lincoln stood on a makeshift wooden platform and delivered his memorial speech.

But more on that on Monday.

Bart


0 Comments

Still shaking out a bad back... will be back on Friday for sure with some "Fourscore and Seven Years" facts you may have never seen before!

11/27/2013

0 Comments

 
0 Comments

illness calls for a pause... I'll be back on Friday, sorry folks.

11/20/2013

0 Comments

 
0 Comments

Did the US Post inadvertently  "Stamp" out  an injustice of November 11th?

11/18/2013

0 Comments

 
I think so!

Here was the national injustice in my mind....
Picture
You could not help from seeing the images on the news for 15 days when the government of the US was shut down. It affected about 800,000 spread across the US and no doubt foreign offices around the world. The above images were at the National World War 11 Memorial at Washington DC. The bottom right shows a veteran who was banned from entry on risk of being arrested.

I witnessed open spaces being banned in DC and at Gettysburg were you could not walk across an open fields on all sides of numerous monuments dedicated to those who fought and many lost their lives to protect their way of life. Open spaces like the DC monument left the vets and others wondering why and puzzled at the reasons for boarding up open spaces for reasons most could not fathom.

Picture
Well folks, in an unintended way, the people at the US Post made things better at the WW 11 Memorial on Veterans Day, (Canada's Remembrance Day) when they unveiled a new series of two stamps that will no doubt be very well received by the veterans and hopefully all citizens.

The image on the left shows the Lincoln Memorial at DC, in the foreground. At the top of the picture is the Washington Memorial Tower off at a distance to the East. Not clear in the image, but just this side of the base of the tower is where the WW11 Memorial stands.

The image ought to look familiar to those who saw the movie Forest Gump and the crowd scene when he stood at the base of the Lincoln monument and the crowd were in front of him with the tower at their backs. The image on the right is now looking back westward towards the Lincoln Monument at the top of the image.

At the bottom is a good image of the National WW11 Memorial.

Picture
This map should look familiar to regular readers. Arlington Cemetery is o to the right at item "A." Item "B" shows the Lincoln Memorial with the Potomac River separating these two historic sites. To the right of "B" is the Reflecting Pool and at "C" is the WW11 Memorial. Item "D" is of course the Washington Monument and up at the top, item "E" shows the location of the White House.

Picture
Many members of the military family, veterans and members of the public gathered on Veterans Day to see the unveiling of these stamps. While over 16 million wore the American uniform and went off to war, only 464 men were awarded the prestigious medal. Almost half of these were posthumous awards, meaning of course the recipient lost his life in the action resulting in the award.

The US Post wanted to continue the preservation of the stories of these heroes and approached each one of the remaining 12 WW11 recipients still alive awhile back and obtained their permissions to use their pictures on a cover sheet that was issued with the above stamps, 20 per package. But sadly, by unveiling date 4 of the heroes had passed on.

The image on the left is the current Navy and Marine Medal of Honor. The large image on its right is that of the Army. In WW11 there were no officially designed medals for the air force and they did not receive their own till 1965.

Picture












Ninety-two year old George Sakato, MOH recipient, and the widow of MOH recipient, the late Senator Daniel Iouye's wife pulled the cord that unveiled publicly for the first time the new stamps.

Picture
The second fellow on the left is MOH recipient  William Ross, and 2nd from right is MOH recipient Harvey Barnum and the Postmaster General of the US... Mr. Patrick Donahoe. To the right is a cover page that comes with the purchase of a sheet on the new stamps. It shows the images of the 8 living, and 4 deceased men... the last dozen recipients from WW11. Inside, but not shown, is a complete list of all the recipients from the war. I will bring you an image of this at a later date. It should include the names of two Canadians., and a third with a connection to Canada.

While the ceremony was going on at this monument, the President was across the river at Arlington...and laying a wreath at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier.

Over 500 were said to have stood in line for over an hour to speak to the Medal of Honor men at the stamp unveiling ceremony and collect keepsake autographs.

Picture
Not far away stands the Washington Monument, that stands over 555 feet...by a few inches and is the tallest stone tower and also the tallest obelisk in the world.

It got its start in 1848 and not finished until 1884. For a period of about 23 years work on it was put on hold during the UNCIVIL War and the term of the infamous DO NOTHING GOVERNMENT. Look very carefully at the colour for the first quarter of its height. It is darker. That's when  halting stopped for so many years. 

When I was in DC I noticed that there is scaffolding all around the tower. It is shut down to the public as a result of damages sustained from the recent earthquake in Virginia and Hurricane Irene.  It is expected to open next year to the public again.

But here is how it looks more recently.... The upper right is at about the 500 ft mark. Note the size of the half dozen workman in comparison to the tower itself.

Picture
The bottom right gives an example of the damage found and needing repairs. Image being at the base if a chuck of it lands... and probably makes its own crater. hehe.

And for those who would love a fee trip to DC here's a link to the city and a closer look at the tower this very minute.  http://www.earthcam.com/usa/dc/washingtonmonument/?cam=washmon 

That's all for today...

Bart

0 Comments

Two stories that ask... Is it a Congressional Medal of Honor or a Medal of Honor

11/15/2013

0 Comments

 
Way back in December of last year, with one of my very first blogs, I wrote an article about the Medal of Honor and the Grand Army of the Republic membership badge and gave illustrations in that blog. It can be read for lots of detail regarding both items at.. http://www.canadianmedalofhonor.com/1/post/2012/12/and-now-a-look-at-the-army-civil-war-medals-of-honor.html

Well earlier this week many interesting things happened while I was manning my booth at the BC Museum for Remembrance celebrations. It was the fifth time I had a booth about the Canadian Medal of Honor recipients displayed at the event.

A fellow appearing to be a vet came up to the booth and starting talking about the MOH and then pointed to three medals he was wearing. They appeared to be American and perhaps Vietnam era medals. He said that one was the CONGRESSIONAL GOLD MEDAL OF HONOR. I of course told him that there was no such thing. There was however a CONGRESSIONAL GOLD MEDAL. Having seen and held one of them a few years back I knew that he was mistaken and that none of those worn was such a prestigious medal. He wandered off and reappeared later and called it something else. He allowed me to take a photo and I will later try to identify each of the three medals on  a later date.

Then another fellow and his wife approached the booth and while talking the couple mentioned that a grandfather fought in the Civil War and when he passed away he left a trunk with some military papers and several medals in it. When he described one of the medals, it sounded like a Medal of Honor. When I showed them images of the MOH they said that it looked a lot like what they had. When they mentioned that it was in a box.. I showed them a picture of a CW army MOH in a presentation box and they think that was what they had. They even added that the ribbon looked familiar.

I was like a kid in a candy store because  having another MOH found in Canada would be great. There are only a handful, less than a dozen that I know of... and only two currently on public display. Two more will hopefully also be put on public display but I await news on that front.

Meanwhile, since we first met the couple have now emailed me several images, great shots of two different medals thought to be the MOH and  several other images. 
Picture















These four images are not the Medal of Honor. All are images of the GAR badge of membership. The first two are off the internet  and shown the authorized front and back of the badge. The third is another image off the net and the fourth is the image sent to me by the couple. The first and second are the legitimate first approved ribbon and its positioning. The ribbon on the third is misaligned. It comes in a long strip and the field of stars are supposed to be at the top... not bottom. The fourth is the first I have ever seen of this ribbon, though that is not to say it is not a valid ribbon.

Picture















This is an enlarged image of the reverse of the GAR badge. Note its major differences with the reverse of an actual Medal of Honor on the right that gives the name of the recipient, the date and place of the event usually.

Picture
Along with images of the front and back of the first GAR badge, the couple sent along the centre image of another GAR badge. It seems for some unknown reason this fellow may have has dwo of them. Also the ribbon looks strange.  I have  yet to see another like this one.

On the right of course is the real Medal of Honor, a Civil War army model.

Note the position of the ribbon on all medals. The real one never touches the actual medal until years later when the device was made to be word around your neck.  But the GAR ones always seem to touch it. Note also the image of the eagle is slightly different and in the MOH it rests above 8 cannon balls, but the GAR has ten.

Picture









Also emailed to me were these images of an army Colonel's rank and may be indicative of a GAR status as the commander of one of its posts across the US.

Picture


























In 1866 Doctor Benjamin Stephenson started an organization that would, in the years to come grow to almost 1/2 million members. It would be the equivalent to today's legion and was called the Grand Army of the Republic. Its goals were those that aided the returning veterans and programs were conducted nationally with representation for every state in the country. These "departments" would be further broken down in community branches... or posts. The group was most influential on the political and military fronts and its membership boasted many of the highest naval and army ranks and included 5 men who would go on to become President of the United Sates.

One of it goals was to better the vet's lives by the creation of pensions for them. They pressured the government to create such benefits. While a men's organization, they did allow one women in. She even got a pension and, at her death was given a full military funeral. You have read about her in these blogs in the past. Her name was Sarah Emma Edmundston (aka Edmunds) ...and she was a Canadian from New Brunswick.

One of the earliest programs the GAR created was what would become known as Decoration Day. On such a day you were ordered by the GAR to go to veterans graves and lay flowers and plant a flag and show your respect. Today that day is known as Memorial Day in the US.

The above monument, only a few minutes walk from the congressional buildings at DC... and the Canadian embassy, by the way, was dedicated back in 1909 and is now listed in the US National Registry of  Historic Places. I admired it numerous times while in the downtown DC area recently. 

From the above images you can well see the trouble folks had for years in identifying the real medal from the badge. This was a part of the underlying issued that moved the government forward on the famous purge of 1916 that costs so many men their LIGITIMATE Medals of Honor, as you have no doubt read in this space several times.

But enough for today.

Bart


0 Comments

Remembrance 2013

11/13/2013

1 Comment

 
This has been a very busy week for me. About a week ago I had to prepare a short talk on my trip to the US  for the genealogy society of which I belong. I've also had to prepare to make some remarks at the annual remembrance ceremony at Royal Oak Cemetery where regular readers know a ceremony was conducted recently in honour of Rowland Bourke, VC, DSO and Belgian MOH. I had to also prepare for a brief slide show and talk at the BC Museum with regards to the Gettysburg connection in Canada, and also make sure my booth was ship shape for showing at the 5th remembrance show I was invited to participate in there on the 11th. To top all this off I had to prepare to appear on a live radio interview at CFAX here in Victoria BC.  Thus  the cancelling of the Friday and Monday columns last.

All of these activities involved the bringing forth of stories about these brave Canadians who earned either the US Medal of Honor or the British Commonwealth's Victoria Cross.

But before today's comments I would like to ask you to check out each of the following 6 videos. Each is most moving and all on topic at a time when we stop in Canada to reflect on the history, the stories and sacrifices of those now serving in uniform, and those who came before them. Each in their own way was.. .or is... a hero. As are those left behind to carry on as they do their jobs so that you and I can enjoy the incredible freedoms we do enjoy, and more often than not, take for granted.

Today is payback day!

Watch first this very moving video of a 4 year old boy in Belgian in 2007. His mother made up a little uniform for him and it appears to be that of the Canadian Scottish here in Victoria. This little fellow gave his outmost respect to Canadian soldiers in Belgium marching on honour of the liberation of Belgium by Canadian troops so many years ago. Here it is. And please note the respect the child receives in return.

enjoy...  http://www.wimp.com/belgianboy/       hit exit to come back to blog when finished for this and the others...  

Having served in the military for 17 years and attended some form of celebration for about 40 years, you can be assured that I have heard the last post being played many a time. But never like this. This is incredible. It is played by a 13 year old from Holland a few years back and will bring a tear to most viewers eye. And so it should.

Please enjoy....       http://www.flixxy.com/trumpet-solo-melissa-venema.htm

We have all seen and heard of the price Canada is playing in the current war on terrorism. We hear of and see the men and women who have given their all and could give no more for our benefit. We can never really appreciate all the loss these hero's families and friends and neighbours will feel for generations since their loved one was taken away from them..

Canadian Rock Legend Brian Adams helps us to cope with this sorrow with his tune...Never Let Go. If only we can live up to his words. Here they are...   http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=luo4BseF9ukhttp://

Jack Lord also brings us powerful thoughts with his tune... Highway of Heroes. Give it a listen at... 
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=34n4AJu2mkg

And before leaving the music scene I want to bring you this great song by Lee Greenwood... Proud to be a Canadian....
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ckfXr1EHO9U

  
Picture














A few weeks back when I had the privilege of visiting the Canadian embassy, I was given a tour of many areas of the incredible facility. I had a wonderful chat of about 2 hours and whilst there I was shown a medallion about 2 inches in diameter as shown above.

The military contingent of the embassy apparently arranged for this commemorative token to be designed and minted in the amount of  a very limited 750 copies. Numbers 1 and 750 have been dedicated to the unknown soldier at Arlington. The purpose of the coin is to recognize the sacrifices of both the US and Canadian troops who have lost their lives in battle. I suspect the coin is also in recognition of the very positive working relationship that has been developed over the years... perhaps even going back to Civil War days when some 50,000 served in US uniforms of the day.

The face of the coin spells Defence  with a C, as we do in Canada, and the reverse spells it with an S as they do in the US. Each side also bears the Canadian flag along the rim and the white star of the US along the opposite rim. The coins are carefully controlled and issued to certain officials to present  to high officials as they go about their day to day work.  I was most pleased to be presented with one of these coins and shall place it among my most treasured possessions.

Picture
On November 11 I attended another Remembrance Ceremony at the grave of Commander Rowland Bourke, the WW1 naval officer who was awarded the Victoria Cross, the Distinguished Service Order and the Belgian Medal of Honor for his bravery in Belgium 95 years ago. Regular readers have read much about him in past columns here.

At the left are a few of the sailors from the HMS Mallahat reserve navy unit in Victoria and at centre is an image of the unit's acting Coxswain and the unit's Executive Office placing a wreath At the right are some of Rowland Bourke's descendants in attendance. After that ceremony I had to rush down to the radio station for the interview. You can actually here it by going here... http://www.cfax1070.com/Media/CFAX-Podcasts/CFAX-Afternoons/November-11-2013-11am

Picture









On Sunday and Monday of this week the BC Museum... for the 12 year in a row,  housed a remembrance show that included guest speakers at a podium, and numerous booths for groups and individuals to bring in displays on topic. The above are a few of my posters created over the years and this was the fifth such show I attended bringing  the story of the Medal of Honor and its Canadian connection to the public at the museum.

The gathering was well attended and each group no doubt got much very positive feedback for their efforts. I also got may leads to follow up on re the work I have been doing in this regard.

That's it for today... see you on Friday, and in the mean time, if you like what you saw and heard today...PLEASE pass it on to your friends.

And comments on the blog are always welcome too,

Bart


1 Comment

Still more gleanings from the US Archives, part 3...

11/6/2013

0 Comments

 
Well folks, the time has come. I have been telling you for days that I am going to bring you some important news regarding my research at the archives. And today's the day.

But it starts with a caveat... you ought to really reread four earlier posts on today's subject. You can do that now, or come back to them after reading today's post. It will be a brief recap and then the news. But for the fuller story, go back to the earlier ones as well.

They are at...  
http://www.canadianmedalofhonor.com/1/post/2013/01/yesterdays-4-heroes-may-have-two-medals-of-honor.html

http://www.canadianmedalofhonor.com/1/post/2013/01/heros-full-story-yet-to-be-properly-credited.html
 
http://www.canadianmedalofhonor.com/1/post/2013/11/more-gleanings-from-the-us-archives-part-2.html

http://www.canadianmedalofhonor.com/1/post/2013/02/did-they-get-one-medal-of-honor-or-two.html

The story is about Charles Robinson and three other sailors from Civil War days. Charles was born in Scotland and  came to the US and served throughout the war in the navy. He then moved to Nova Scotia, got married, raised a family and spent the rest of his life there and is even buried there. The three other sailors were Peter Cotton, Pierre Leon and John MacDonald. There is no known connection between Canada and these later three. But all were awarded a Medal of Honor. Or was it two?

All four were on a ship called the USS St Louis in early February of 1862 when it and other ships and the army did battle with two Confederate forts known as Henry and Donelson The South lost on both accounts. The union vessels then became involved in numerous skirmishes including at what became known as Island 10. Soon after this the navy discovered that the USS St Louis had to undergo a name change. It was recently purchased from private interests and made shipshape for war service. But the navy did not do its homework. They already had a ship of the same name and so now they had to change the name to something else.  Thus,  from then on it was known as the Baron De Kalb.

Under the new name it and several other vessels took part in what became know as the Yazoo Expedition.

During this time the USS St Louis/Baron de Kalb not only had two different names, it was involved in major battles at the forts and in the Yazoo. But these were in two different states and several hundred miles apart. The later  also occurred 10 months after the battle at the forts.

Not too complicated I guess!

But then there was another factor. There was another Charles Robinson... who also was awarded a Medal of Honor for actions on yet another ship... the USS Galena. His medal was forfeited because he later apparently deserted. I say apparently because there are plenty of cases of a soldier or sailor going missing because he was in a hospital or POW and mislabelled as a deserter. From the discoveries I have made over the years, what one says sometimes is completely wrong.

A critical reading of the various sites that provide information on who earned a MOH, when and for what clearly shows that in the case with these four, the description of the events leading up to the medal slightly change over the years. They ought not to have done so. But the gist of all suggest that the awards were for actions during the Yazoo incident.

I have yet to find the actual document written by any commanding officer connected with the Yazoo incident that says what these four men did and when to be so awarded. There is a general description of what the vessel did though.  Further complicating matters, the ship, regardless of name, went through several officers commanding during the periods concerned, none served at both the first and last mentioned incidents so they could not possibly recommend on other actions other than the one they had first hand knowledge of.

Yet the citations say the commanding officer recommended the men, giving no details of exactly what they did, other than general mission information, with an added caveat.. "and for other actions" How could they recommend for other actions when they were not even there?  Dahhh!

The citation does not even have the name of the commanding officer who made the recommendations.

The records are messed up. They have the deserting Robinson on the non deserting Robinson's ship. They have both being born in same month and year and place which is wrong.

If the men were involved in several actions and the award was for a lot of activity at each, one would think the most prevalent action would be listed with the generic comment added at the end of the citation re... "other actions," And a very close read of the wording says most distinctly that the other actions were during the Yazoo activity.

So, it would be most fair to conclude that the medal was earned for actions at the Yazoo...including minor actions at the same place... and not elsewhere.

So far so good.

But then reality steps in. I can not find any medal for Pierre Leon. But his file tells that it can not be found cause it sank with all his possessions when the Baron De Kalb was sunk by a torpedo. In fact, the Leon file has documents from family seeking a duplicate medal and being told by the navy that IT HAS NO RECORD OF WHAT THE INSCRIPTION ON THE MEADAL WAS and then the head of the bureau   an ADMIRAL no less... sent a BLANK medal to the family and allowed it to inscribe whatever they wanted DAAAAA!  I can find no record of what they wrote. Perhaps that he flew to the moon!

What I also cannot find are any files so far on MacDonald or his medal, or what is written on it despite what all the normal references say it is for.

To really complicate matters, the Peter Cotton medal has been located And so has the Robinson medal. They have identical inscriptions, and they say nothing about the Yazoo. They are clearly inscribed for bravery  at the battles of Fort Henry and Fort Donelson.  I have images of both to prove this.

I have written to the naval department and the Congressional Medal of Honor Society about this matter on more than one occasion and neither can offer any suggestions on why the two medals found or so inscribed.

My argument of course, based on the above, and much better detailed in the referenced earlier blogs, is that Cotton and Robinson and probably the other two did not get a Medal of Honor. They got two, and the 2nd in all cases has yet to surface.

But then came the trip to the archives.  Darn it!

Like the handful of files I was able to locate, the Robinson pension file has a lot of information previously unknown to me. Gems including dates of service and ships on before and after the well noted Yazoo incident on the internet were located.  Information about his home and business in Halifax and the fact that he owned other properties was of interest as well as the fact that he was a landlord of sorts in the late 1800's and early 1900's. Also noted in the file was a little about his naval service plus tidbits about a battle at Island 10. It was here that one of the big, one of the big guns near his gun position was blown up. As a result of this several men were killed and a dozen including him were wounded. One of the dead was thrown across the deck and landed on him. This caused internal problems in one leg, and a screwed up ankle and eventually rheumatism developed in both legs which would later form part of the justification for a pension. 

Here is one of the documents found in his file. It as from back in 1880. 
Picture

This is the first part  of a 2 page document that  was sent along to  the office of the Treasury Department. The lawyer writing asked what  was happening with the Robinson application for a pension.

Attached to the first page was a sketch that a child would make of the medal.  Something akin to a child's rubbing of a coin.

The sketch was almost a rubbing of the inscription as noted at the left.

It was this description, and the entirely different story about why a medal was awarded, plus numerous discrepancies as noted in earlier blogs that set me off on a search for over 5 years to see if this man and the other three did not have just one, but two Medals of Honor.

Another document found in the file was a letter from Charles' wife after he died. His pension  was approved and collected on for years but cancelled when he died. It was then up to the wife to apply and go through another process to qualify for it to continue, and at  a lower rate of course.  

Picture
This letter was written to the Pension Bureau and was a few pages long. the first is at the bottom of pg 1 and the lower portion the top of pg 2. the sunlight obviously did a number of one of the pages.

Regardless, there are two things that have jumped out at me in seeing this letter. First off, it says the medal was awarded according to what Charles said over the years of the marriage, for actions in spiking the guns at both Forts. But as you have seen from above, that's not what the reference materials all say. They argue it was for actions on the Yazoo.

As interesting, she mentions spiking guns. So does the pension file for Pierre Leon. But his files say that the spiking took place at Island 10. So now we have 3 locations were the heroism is rewarded for. The Yazoo, the Forts and Island 10.

Leaving the geography aside, something else jumped out at me. Here is a woman who was married to Charles for about 3 decades. She talks about his medal and uses the term...THE medal. If there were two, would she not make reference to two medals, Surely if two, she would have known about it.

There's more!

Later in the same file I found the closest thing I may ever get to the smoking gun... if you will.  A hand written account of his service of several pages in length that HE WROTE.  And here is an entry from that report...

Picture








Note his comment that they spiked the guns off island ten. He was part of the same crew spiking the guns and one of them... Leon claims to have the medal for spiking guns... and Charles wife says he claimed spiking guns (though at wrong place, maybe) and now Charles says he was spiking guns. Could the inscription on his medal just be plain wrong. YES.

But as they say on all those TV commercials... Wait... there's more... 

Picture










Here in his own handwriting Charles Robinson says that he received a bronze medal (the Medal of Honor) and noted how it was described as being for actions at the Forts' But the point I want to make here is that he says he got A MEDAL... if he got two would he not have noted a 2nd one as well!

I think so!

So folks, while I believe that all the evidence seemed to suggest that he and at least  one if not all three others noted here got two medals, the constant reference to one medal seems to suggest that I may have gotten this wrong.

Until further information comes forth I therefore will concede begrudgingly, that it appears Charles Robinson only got one Medal of Honor.

As if that is not enough on its own.

Cheers, and please note that I am taking a break on Friday to prepare for three November 11 events and  presentations I will be making on the Canadian recipients of the medal. Monday of course is the holiday, so I will be back next Wednesday. 

In the mean those north of the border can celebrate Nov 11 even going back to the War of 1812. It was on 11 November 1813 that we taught the Americans a lesson at Crysler's Farm but we are buddies now. And on Nov 11 1865 Mary Walker's Medal of Honor was approved by President Johnson. It had earlier been approved by President Lincoln but with his death it was revisited by Johnson and implemented.

So lots to consider on the 11th folks.

Bart


0 Comments

More Gleanings from the US Archives, part 2

11/4/2013

0 Comments

 
I guess one of the hazards of doing research is that you are eventually bound to find out that some of the heroes being researched  had... shall we say...issues... during their military careers, before or after. Guess they all were human!

Today I want to briefly touch on two files that produced some unexpected results.

First I will start whith Toronto born Lieutenant Edward Paul Doherty. who by age 20 or 21 went off to the US and served in several different regiments during the Civil War. He was relatively unknown as an officer until he was selected by the War Department to head off with some troops to capture John Wilkes Booth, the assassin of President Abraham Lincoln. He went off and accomplished his task and became famous for doing so. You can read my blog about him at...  http://www.canadianmedalofhonor.com/1/post/2013/03/9-years-and-5-regiments-served-a-pow-international-hero-but-no-medal-of-honor.html  

But it is service before and after that stunned me. Let's begin with this entry in an official document of the US Adjutant  General's office  in December of 1888. It comes from the Doherty widow's application files for a pension. 
Picture












Here you can see that Lt. Doherty, years before his capture of Booth, had some tough times in the service. He was caught absent without leave and later it was discovered that he was apparently under the influence of liquor for over a month. His commanding officer, in giving an honourable discharge... was being more than kind to him. Possibly in the hopes that he would learn his lesson.

Picture
Soon he would rejoin the military but not long after he would again resign on the grounds of some unexplained "family  affair."

Picture



Upon re-enlisting yet again, he would again go missing from duties. Turns out he was under arrest and held in a camp jail but no information had been found yet what he was accused of.

In Dec 1870 some sort of a special Board was held and ordered, that due to a "lack of good morale character,"  he be  dismissed from further service in the military and so came the end to his military career.

What ever his crimes, they however cannot take away from his efforts to capture the very man who assassinated the President of the United States.

And now onto something a little more positive...

I have mentioned Lt Samuel W. Preston several times in past blogs claiming that he was most deserving of a Medal of Honor in past blogs. Sam was about 24 years old and like Doherty was an Ontario man. But instead of Toronto he came from London, a few hours drive west of Toronto. He was a navy man and was as qualified, if not more so than most to be awarded the medal. But because of the rules of the day, the navy officers could not be so awarded. So they did the next best things. Over the years they named not one war ship BUT SIX after him. Something the history teacher forgot to teach us.
 
I had a chance to peak into some records in DC and discover a  most interesting find... and here it is... 

Picture
Picture
The US Navy sent this out to all stations and it seems pretty strong language to suggest that all recipients will do their best to comply with the raising of funds to create a monument for Sam Preston at Annapolis.

I have not found any such structure in my initial research but will be pursuing what was done in this regards and bring news as it becomes available.

Here is a marker at Annapolis that obviously cries for some attention. He took his training there and graduated first of his class in 1862. 

Please have a look at the earlier blogs about this officer at...

http://www.canadianmedalofhonor.com/1/post/2013/01/1.html
and...   http://www.canadianmedalofhonor.com/1/post/2013/01/a-canadian-medal-of-honorthat-wasnt-awarded.html
and ...  http://www.canadianmedalofhonor.com/1/post/2013/01/two-navy-one-marine-and-one-army-medal-of-honor.html

This blog is getting too long so I will leave the best till last.. on Wednesday.

Bart




0 Comments

More Gleanings from the US Archives part 2

11/1/2013

0 Comments

 
On Wednesday I posted some of the actual documents I discovered when looking at some of the files of Canadian Medal of Honor men and others of historic importance. I showed a few incidents of humor in the files and some of the Medal of Honor men's files, and evidence of the common practice throughout the Civil War of many that used nicknames. Names that often caused them problems years down the road when they, or there widows attempted to get pensions for injuries sustained. The blog also brought images of an early Honor Roll book that listed the men thought to be then the current holders of the honor. I ended with pictures of the actual Muster Book for the USS Agawam for some of the months during the Civil War.  An incredible book that was over 150 years old.

The act of searching out pension files is less than straight forward. There are lots of curves to slow down the journey. If the fellow's name was Robert Smith... then you will find a zillion pension files of that name. If he was in the army then you need to search the unit's records. There could be dozens of the same names in the unit. You need other identifiers such as age or place of enlistment etc. Maybe the fellow did not make a claim for a pension. Maybe he was using a middle name or one made up. Maybe he had four different files... all in different names. It goes on and on.

When and if you finally hit pay dirt, you will find all kinds of very depressing stories about the ailments of the individual and why he feels entitled to a pension. And then you will often find all kinds of roadblocks to his getting the pension. And if he died while drawing it, you then may find a widow left on her own and without much in the way of means, and up against a bureaucracy that send her lots of loopholes to jump through to get a widow's pension.  And all this for sometimes amounts of $6 or 8 or 10 a month or even less. I saw one that was raised by less then a dollar after being been drawn for years.

I am going to briefly bring you two cases with a few of the actually letters seeking pensions to show some of this systemic harshness and the incredible burdens it put on those most in need. Both turned out successfully...but not  before much time was lost in fighting the system and causing much grief enroute as the letters clearly show. 
Picture
Past blogs have mentioned the story of Thomas J Higgins. Born in Quebec, he went off to war as a youth and faced 100 men on an enemy line that managed to kill or repel all his unit except himself. While UNARMED he charged forward and placed his units colours,  which he carried as a volunteer, on their emplacement. He was captured, made a POW and later released. His MOH came some 30 years later after the ENEMY kept pushing for him to get the medal for his bravery. His medal was the only one eventually awarded to anyone in this regiment.

Now the widowed wife had to fight to get a widows pension. The above, while difficult to read says that she found it difficult to find their excuse acceptable that they had found 4 men with the same name. She added how many had the same name for his wife? She also complained, as above written, that she could not understand their repeated requests that she fill out blanks on forms when they knew that she did not have his discharge papers, papers that were lost in a fire. The widow also noted that she knew other soldiers that knew him and that they had told her that she clearly was entitled to pension and told the pension office she had no intent on giving up the fight to get it. 

Picture
In a follow-up letter she pleads to get the matter sorted out and how much it meant to her financially. Adding that she was getting on in years, she noted that her husband served his country and that she ought to be better treated and that..."I hope this  does not find it's way to the waste basket," and begged that that if the matter could be hastened it  would have been most appreciated.

Picture
From the above letter you can see how inconsiderate the pension bureau was to her plight. It basically said that if the  widow cannot find the paperwork for her husband, that was her problem. It offered no solution to her dilemma. Such as what department could look for the file for her. A lonely old women who's dead husband's records were burnt in a fire, and who's copies were held by government. A government that appears to have not given a hoot about her. Yet her husband was a war hero and who's death was partly caused, according to the wife, by health issues caused whilst in service to his country. Hmmm!

After the ILLEGAL purge of 1917, the government sent along this certificate (on right, above) telling that his name was still on the Honor Roll of US Heroes and outlined the actions that resulted in his getting his MOH... about 30 years later... and not at the action of government but at the pushing of his, and his country's  former enemies. A document on file when they originally refused the pension. A decision later reversed.

Picture
Picture
Past blogs have brought the readers much information  about Charles Robinson who earned a medal of Honor in the Civil War. He later moved to Nova Scotia, married, relocated to Halifax and stayed there for over 30 years and raised a family,  died and to this day lays at rest there.

There has been a major development in his story which I had hoped to bring you today but time and space are proving problematic. It will have to wait till the next blog, as will be the most interesting information on yet another Canadian hero covered in this space in the past. 

These aside, above is another part of the story of Halifax's Charles Robinson. This hero's attempts to secure a pension and not being well treated by government are indicative, by some of the material in this letter. He would get a pension but not without a fight. A fight at a time in his life he didn't need one.

Charles was a navy man and on board a boat that was sunk by the Confederates. One of the massive cannons on that ship was blown up as where many of the men around it. The explosion knocked him across the ship and threw a dead sailor on top of him. He got minor scraps but these disappeared over the years. But he had internal injuries not readily obvious to the naked eye.

As noted above, the military wanted evidence of scars that he did not have. They then wanted a statement from an officer supporting his claim who was not even on the ship at the time. They then were told, that Charles had met other men drawing pensions when they apparently did not even serve. They paid others to do it for them... something legal at the time and known as substitute service. Charles noted that while he served and got injured and cannot get a pension these men got them without even serving. He added that he was also duped out of moneys owed him for the capture of some enemy vessels. This was known as Prize Money and was common through most of the war. The ship would be sold and the funds split up to all crew.

In his case another man used his name and managed to collect the money. The imposter was later caught and thrown in jail. But the government could not recover the money they gave out in error, and said that it was too bad but there was none left for him.   Hmmm!
 
In another letter not shown, he fought with the government when it decided that if a pensioner was no longer living in the US, he could not draw any pension unless he had taken out citizenship. Charles already had.  But he was cut off anyway till his argument could be advanced, considered and then later action taken to start the pension again.

After he died his pension was again cancelled and his widow then had to take up the fight encountering her own  frustrations before finally starting to get the funds entitled to all along. 

The files located at the archives have also revealed many details about the men not readily known. Places of birth, birth dates, terms of service, war injuries and  service in other regiments or boats before or after the event where the medal was earned can be found in many of these files. I even found one of the MOH man fighting at Gettysburg before he later earned a MOH.

And then there are the three gems I have been promising you.

They will appear in the next blog.  Trust me.  This time!

Bart

0 Comments

    Author;
    Bart Armstrong, C.D.,
    Recipient, Sovereign's Medal for Volunteers 

    Archives

    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly